Why do we model Railroads?

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Bruce Favinge » Thu, 28 Mar 2002 02:32:12



I was working on a car kit last night at the dining room table completely
content, when my daughter asked why I was building another car just like
some I already have. I started to answer when she went on to ask "for that
matter dad, why do you even want to build a model railroad at all? its seems
so juvenile." I just looked at her and all I could think to say is a line
from the song Locomotive Breath "Old Charlie stole the handle and the train
won't stop going no way to slow down." She looked at me like I was nuts and
went off to take a phone call. That got me wondering. The truth of the
matter is I don't really know why I enjoy model railroading or why I like
trains. I just have as long as I can remember. It's been mentioned that it
brings back fond childhood memories but I enjoyed model railroading as a
child when there where no childhood memories to look back on, fond or
otherwise. The need to be creative doesn't seem to be it. I have fun getting
a new RTR locomotive or shake the box car kit as much as I do scratch
building. As far as recognition goes I doubt any one would be impressed with
my trains and I don't care if anyone is, and never went out of my way to
show what I have built to anyone. When it comes to my railroad I prefer to
be left alone with it and have only fleetingly considered joining a club as
away to see and run really large locomotives and long trains. So
companionship though I certainly enjoy good company is not the reason
either. Do any of you really know why you model trains other than that you
like to and have fun doing it. Just curious. Bruce
 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Joseph M. Ferri » Thu, 28 Mar 2002 02:41:50


For me, it is a way to reconstruct the history of my life.  I grew up right
next to the tracks, and the trains that would roll by my bedroom window
always fascinated me...

As a child, I tried to mimic what I say from my window so that it could be
me that was in control of something so large and powerful.  I went through a
period after that, when the tracks were torn up and I moved away, that the
interest had left me too.

Now, as I have long since left school and got on with life, the fascination
that I had at the time is fascinating to me now, if that makes any sense.

I look at it as being a slice of time in my life where there was a pure
magic and I did not know how to share that emotion.  Now, I try to do so by
recreating that magic.

--

Joseph


Quote:
> I was working on a car kit last night at the dining room table completely
> content, when my daughter asked why I was building another car just like
> some I already have. I started to answer when she went on to ask "for that
> matter dad, why do you even want to build a model railroad at all? its
seems
> so juvenile." I just looked at her and all I could think to say is a line
> from the song Locomotive Breath "Old Charlie stole the handle and the
train
> won't stop going no way to slow down." She looked at me like I was nuts
and
> went off to take a phone call. That got me wondering. The truth of the
> matter is I don't really know why I enjoy model railroading or why I like
> trains. I just have as long as I can remember. It's been mentioned that it
> brings back fond childhood memories but I enjoyed model railroading as a
> child when there where no childhood memories to look back on, fond or
> otherwise. The need to be creative doesn't seem to be it. I have fun
getting
> a new RTR locomotive or shake the box car kit as much as I do scratch
> building. As far as recognition goes I doubt any one would be impressed
with
> my trains and I don't care if anyone is, and never went out of my way to
> show what I have built to anyone. When it comes to my railroad I prefer to
> be left alone with it and have only fleetingly considered joining a club
as
> away to see and run really large locomotives and long trains. So
> companionship though I certainly enjoy good company is not the reason
> either. Do any of you really know why you model trains other than that you
> like to and have fun doing it. Just curious. Bruce


 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Train Ma » Thu, 28 Mar 2002 05:08:09


Do you really need a reason other than you enjoy it? Isn't that what a
hobby is supposed to be?

Jeff

Quote:

> I was working on a car kit last night at the dining room table completely
> content, when my daughter asked why I was building another car just like
> some I already have. I started to answer when she went on to ask "for that
> matter dad, why do you even want to build a model railroad at all? its seems
> so juvenile." I just looked at her and all I could think to say is a line
> from the song Locomotive Breath "Old Charlie stole the handle and the train
> won't stop going no way to slow down." She looked at me like I was nuts and
> went off to take a phone call. That got me wondering. The truth of the
> matter is I don't really know why I enjoy model railroading or why I like
> trains. I just have as long as I can remember. It's been mentioned that it
> brings back fond childhood memories but I enjoyed model railroading as a
> child when there where no childhood memories to look back on, fond or
> otherwise. The need to be creative doesn't seem to be it. I have fun getting
> a new RTR locomotive or shake the box car kit as much as I do scratch
> building. As far as recognition goes I doubt any one would be impressed with
> my trains and I don't care if anyone is, and never went out of my way to
> show what I have built to anyone. When it comes to my railroad I prefer to
> be left alone with it and have only fleetingly considered joining a club as
> away to see and run really large locomotives and long trains. So
> companionship though I certainly enjoy good company is not the reason
> either. Do any of you really know why you model trains other than that you
> like to and have fun doing it. Just curious. Bruce

 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by JB/N » Thu, 28 Mar 2002 06:28:47




Quote:
> Do you really need a reason other than you enjoy it? Isn't that what a
> hobby is supposed to be?

Why am I a model railroader ?

Well, for starters, I've had a lifelong fascination with trains - beign
socially [slightly] disabled, I've found relating to all things
mechanical much easier.

Ahem.

Anyway, a couple years ago, I found myself with too much time on my hands
(being on disability means LOTS of free time!!) .. so I started model
railroading! Having finally chosen gauge and prototype, I'm now busy
working on my layout - my friends say I'm nuts, I spend too much money on
my trains - but, I challenged them to tell me a hobby that DOESN'T cost a
lot of money when pursued seriously!!!!!!

And of course, IT'S FUN!!!!!!!
[And I damn well don't need any other reasons!!!]

--

Modeling Japanese N Gauge - and loving it!
Visit my layout: http://www.xs4all.nl/~tsunami/yumekaigan/

 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Stefan L » Thu, 28 Mar 2002 06:47:45




Quote:
> Do you really need a reason other than you enjoy it? Isn't that what a
> hobby is supposed to be?

> Jeff

BINGO!Isn't that what its all about?

Oh boy, I see this thread going on forever....

 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Tony Burzi » Thu, 28 Mar 2002 11:28:49


Quote:

>I was working on a car kit last night at the dining room table completely
>content, when my daughter asked why I was building another car just like
>some I already have. I started to answer when she went on to ask "for that
>matter dad, why do you even want to build a model railroad at all? its seems
>so juvenile."

It's a guy thing.   You can't explain it to a female, any more than
a female can explain to a guy why you have to talk about things! :-)

Tony Burzio
San Diego, CA

 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Stefan L » Thu, 28 Mar 2002 11:57:11



Quote:


>>I was working on a car kit last night at the dining room table
>>completely content, when my daughter asked why I was building another
>>car just like some I already have. I started to answer when she went on
>>to ask "for that matter dad, why do you even want to build a model
>>railroad at all? its seems so juvenile."

> It's a guy thing.   You can't explain it to a female, any more than
> a female can explain to a guy why you have to talk about things! :-)

I guess this really applies to most hobbies. Hey, I don't think collecting
plates or dolls is cool either! But I don't begrudge them. Just enjoy
whatever you do. That's the whole point of a hobby isn't it? I enjoy my
trains and that's about it. Nothing to "deep" here...it's just a whole lot
of fun trying to figure out how to replicate the consist of SP's Morning
Daylight between SF and LA in 1951:-)
Stefan
 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Vlad2 Ma » Thu, 28 Mar 2002 12:47:09


Quote:
>I started to answer when she went on to ask "for that
>matter dad, why do you even want to build a model railroad at all? its seems
>so juvenile."

Well, and this probably sounds sexist, but most every hobby is a guy thing.
Race cars, guns, wood working, model trains.  It's all a "boys with toys"
thing.  And women rarely understand.  And those that do stand out as notable
exceptions.  Like that NASCAR driver for BAM racing.  

Boys play with toys.  Men play with more expensive toys.  

Frankly, I don't know what women do with their time.  As far as I can tell,
most don't do any of the "fun" stuff.

V II
ps "Juvenile" is what jealous people say about those who are young at heart.

 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Frank A. Rosenbau » Thu, 28 Mar 2002 21:52:19


Bruce, when I was a kid, I lived in a borough of New York City. The only
trains that I saw (infrequently) was the subway. I moved to a suburb when I
was eight and saw only commuter trains when we dropped my dad at the
station. (Scarsdale, NY)

That said, I have been a model railroader since before I can remember (I
have been told this). As a kid, I loved anything with wheels. I tried the
slot cars in the '60's, but they didn't go backwards, like a real car, and
they had two speeds. Off and supersonic. I wanted something in-between and
switched to HO scale from Lionel, when I was 11. I was in control, I was
'god' I had power over something. I built it with my own two hands! I
created it. (And I was pretty good at it too.)
Now, as an ***, I am refining my technique and trying to improve things in
a subject/hobby that not many other people do. I also enjoy getting the
compliments on my modules and techniques when I show them to others. But
mainly, I just enjoy the precision. What other hobby lets you get a similar
view of the real thing and the object of the hobby? You stand trackside, and
get a view of the train, you can build your benchwork so your track is at
eye level and get the same view as trackside. I can't think of any other
hobby that can do this.

I know, I know, I am rambling on and most thoughts aren't too cohesive, but
. . . .
I'll stop now.

--
Frank R.

Please change my entry in your address book.
Thanks.

Quote:
> I was working on a car kit last night at the dining room table completely
> content, when my daughter asked why I was building another car just like
> some I already have. I started to answer when she went on to ask "for that
> matter dad, why do you even want to build a model railroad at all? its
seems
> so juvenile." I just looked at her and all I could think to say is a line
> from the song Locomotive Breath "Old Charlie stole the handle and the
train
> won't stop going no way to slow down." She looked at me like I was nuts
and
> went off to take a phone call. That got me wondering. The truth of the
> matter is I don't really know why I enjoy model railroading or why I like
> trains. I just have as long as I can remember. It's been mentioned that it
> brings back fond childhood memories but I enjoyed model railroading as a
> child when there where no childhood memories to look back on, fond or
> otherwise. The need to be creative doesn't seem to be it. I have fun
getting
> a new RTR locomotive or shake the box car kit as much as I do scratch
> building. As far as recognition goes I doubt any one would be impressed
with
> my trains and I don't care if anyone is, and never went out of my way to
> show what I have built to anyone. When it comes to my railroad I prefer to
> be left alone with it and have only fleetingly considered joining a club
as
> away to see and run really large locomotives and long trains. So
> companionship though I certainly enjoy good company is not the reason
> either. Do any of you really know why you model trains other than that you
> like to and have fun doing it. Just curious. Bruce

 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Charles Kr » Thu, 28 Mar 2002 23:36:09


Quote:



>>>I was working on a car kit last night at the dining room table
>>>completely content, when my daughter asked why I was building another
>>>car just like some I already have. I started to answer when she went on
>>>to ask "for that matter dad, why do you even want to build a model
>>>railroad at all? its seems so juvenile."

>> It's a guy thing.   You can't explain it to a female, any more than
>> a female can explain to a guy why you have to talk about things! :-)

> I guess this really applies to most hobbies. Hey, I don't think collecting
> plates or dolls is cool either! But I don't begrudge them. Just enjoy
> whatever you do. That's the whole point of a hobby isn't it? I enjoy my
> trains and that's about it. Nothing to "deep" here...it's just a whole lot
> of fun trying to figure out how to replicate the consist of SP's Morning
> Daylight between SF and LA in 1951:-)
> Stefan

I've seen some amazing modeling done by the dollhouse crowd.  I've also seen
houses filled with identical off-the-shelf furniture.

But some of the most immersive models I've ever seen were done by diorama
types.  Notably, a former coworker did a garage, complete with oily rags, an
engine block sitting on a workbench, and a Playboy calander, all in (iirc)
1:48.

Actually . . . it sounds a bit like OUR hobby, doesn't it?

 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Steve Capl » Fri, 29 Mar 2002 02:08:51


Quote:

> But some of the most immersive models I've ever seen were done by diorama
> types.  Notably, a former coworker did a garage, complete with oily rags, an
> engine block sitting on a workbench, and a Playboy calander, all in (iirc)
> 1:48.

> Actually . . . it sounds a bit like OUR hobby, doesn't it?

Well, in O scale at least <g>

--
Steve, BFD
"The Silverplate Line"

 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Robert T. Whit » Fri, 29 Mar 2002 02:56:15


Best one I ever heard in response to this question was a quote from an old timer
at a San Francisco  hobby shop.  "Trains are like female ***s.  Both are
intended for children, but it's the father who ends up playing with 'em!"

I do it as stress relief!

Quote:

> >I started to answer when she went on to ask "for that
> >matter dad, why do you even want to build a model railroad at all? its seems
> >so juvenile."

> Well, and this probably sounds sexist, but most every hobby is a guy thing.
> Race cars, guns, wood working, model trains.  It's all a "boys with toys"
> thing.  And women rarely understand.  And those that do stand out as notable
> exceptions.  Like that NASCAR driver for BAM racing.

> Boys play with toys.  Men play with more expensive toys.

> Frankly, I don't know what women do with their time.  As far as I can tell,
> most don't do any of the "fun" stuff.

> V II
> ps "Juvenile" is what jealous people say about those who are young at heart.

 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Fred Dabne » Fri, 29 Mar 2002 04:37:02


Quote:
> > But some of the most immersive models I've ever seen were done
by diorama
> > types.  Notably, a former coworker did a garage, complete with
oily rags, an
> > engine block sitting on a workbench, and a Playboy calander,
all in (iirc)
> > 1:48.

> > Actually . . . it sounds a bit like OUR hobby, doesn't it?

Some years ago, I knew a man who loved those Ertl large
scale truck models. He built them, modified them and did
nice work.  But he had no place to put them afterwards.

I suggested a diorama and he took the idea and ran
with it.

He got a ping-pong table and set it up like a truck stop
with the service plaza, shop, parking and along one edge
a flat for the restaurant, what have you.

Most of the details he scratch built and he said he finally
understood why model railroaders spend so much time
on things that "weren't trains".  He said he'd never had
so much fun in his life, going around to real truck stops,
taking pictures, measurements and strange looks from
the people there.

He started taking pictures of his work using the diorama
for his backdrop, and started making models of some of
the rigs he'd photographed, all of which led to still further
activities like doing models for drivers of their rigs and
so on.

Slowly, it spreads.

Fred D.

 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Frank A. Rosenbau » Fri, 29 Mar 2002 05:14:19


--
Frank R.

Please change my entry in your address book.
Thanks.

Quote:
> He started taking pictures of his work using the diorama
> for his backdrop, and started making models of some of
> the rigs he'd photographed, all of which led to still further
> activities like doing models for drivers of their rigs and
> so on.

> Slowly, it spreads.

Insidious, ain't it??
Quote:
> Fred D.

 
 
 

Why do we model Railroads?

Post by Mark » Fri, 29 Mar 2002 06:20:20


Quote:

> Do any of you really know why you model trains other than that you
> like to and have fun doing it. Just curious. Bruce

Who knows why we are the way we are and why we like certain things
more than others?  We each have our own reasons for our likes and
dislikes. The reasons, consciously or subconsciously, may be simple or
complex.  But the question is not what are the reasons we like model
railroading but rather the question should be why is it we have these
reasons and feelings?  A very complex, deep issue here, indeed.  
Sigmund Freud is dead.  But if you are interested in finding out more
about your true inner-self, check your yellow pages.

My simple, non-professional take on this complex question is that it
would be a pretty boring and mundane world if all humans thought the
same, ate the same food all of the time, all had the same interests,
lived in the exact same type house, and that all males were plumbers
and that all females were teachers, etc..  Mankind wouldn't advance
very far if this "condition".  I think "someone up there" made us all
different "just for the heck of it" to advance mankind and keep us out
of the doldrums. Just think of the millions and millions of things
that would not exist in the world today if each and every male and
each and every female had the exact same makeup?

But as Rodney Dangerfield would say,  "What am I talkin' about?"

Mark